If the Ottawa Senators showed as strong a defence as their general manager did Tuesday, they might still be participating in the NHL playoffs.
John Muckler met with reporters for the first time since his team's exit from the playoffs and quickly found himself on the defensive when it came to explaining the reasons behind his team's quick post-season demise.
While the 72-year-old accepted part of the blame, he showed overwhelming support for a club that's failed to make it out of the second round for the seventh time in eight playoff appearances.
At times, he contradicted criticisms of the team made less than 24 hours earlier by his own coach Bryan Murray. And he insisted he won't blow up the Senators, who finished atop the Eastern Conference standings with 113 points but were eliminated in five games in the second round by the
Buffalo Sabres.
"We are all here for one reason, that's to win the Stanley Cup, and that'll always be the purpose in Ottawa and I think it can be accomplished," said Muckler, who was joined by Senators president Roy Mlakar. "We certainly have to make some changes. I don't think it'll be a great deal of changes. I have all kinds of confidence in our personnel."
With only eight players under contract for next season, the Senators face the loss of key players such as unrestricted free agents Wade Redden and Zdeno Chara and also need to sign restricted free agents like Jason Spezza and Martin Havlat.
Muckler wants them all back - possibly even goaltender
Dominik Hasek, whose injury situation appears to be a bone of contention between the GM and coach. Pending the league's salary cap and Senators owner Eugene Melnyk's own pocketbook, Muckler said he expects to see most of the same faces in the lineup next season.
"When you look at our team, you look at certain people that are being talked about in the newspaper as trading, I don't know how you do those things because I don't think you could get equal value back again," Muckler said.
"Some things have to be done internally - we have to change our ways, change our approach. I still believe in this team. It's a very good hockey club."
Player movement - or lack thereof - seems to be one of a couple of points on which Murray, who Muckler hired to replace Jacques Martin, and the GM don't seem to agree.
After the players cleaned out the dressing room on Monday, Murray had his turn with the media and cited the Senators' goaltending situation as a major reason for its playoff failure.
With Hasek sidelined by a lingering muscle injury in his groin/upper thigh area, the Senators were forced to pin their playoff hopes on the unproven Ray Emery. While Murray said that Emery's performance was good, he thought the 23-year-old backup never should have been put in that situation.
Muckler, who similarly insisted that Patrick Lalime didn't need help shortly before Ottawa's last playoff exit in 2004, chose to stand pat at the trade deadline, a decision that didn't sit well with many critics. From Murray's words, he appears to have joined in those ranks.
"We looked into obtaining a goalkeeper at the deadline - in fact, before the deadline," Muckler countered. "Our options weren't very good. There wasn't anybody available. Emery was the best goalkeeper available."
Murray, clearly annoyed by the distraction Hasek's injury had become to the team, also wants to proceed as though Hasek, an unrestricted free agent, had played his last game for the Senators and said Ottawa's No. 1 off-season priority was finding a suitable replacement.
But Muckler was quick to point to the Senators' lack of offence against the Sabres as the reason for its failure and said he'll even entertain the thought of bringing Hasek back for another year.
"The reason we lost the Stanley Cup is not because of goalkeeping," he said. "This hockey club did not score an even-strength goal after the first game (officially, the Senators were credited with three after Game 1). With the talent that we had in our defence and our forwards, you'd think we'd be able to accomplish that but we never did."
Murray also questioned his team's playoff grit, saying the Senators need to add a couple of forwards "that come and play with that intensity, that character, that grit, whatever it may be, that I believe is really important at this time of year."
While a quick look at the faces of players on teams still in contention reveals a multitude of welts, cuts and black eyes - the tell-tale signs of playoff warriors, there was an absence of battle scars on the fresh faces that cleaned out the locker-room the day before. But Muckler insisted his guys were tough enough.
"I thought we had a lot of grit on our hockey club this year as compared to previous seasons," he said.
After being unable to follow up on previous strong regular-season performances and recognizing their window of opportunity may be coming to a close with new free-agency rules and the salary cap, this was supposed to be the year the Senators went for it.
However, after last summer's blockbuster deal that brought in Dany Heatley from Atlanta in exchange for Marian Hossa and Greg de Vries, Muckler made few other moves.
Muckler insists he liked what he saw all along and felt teams wanted too much to make deals worthwhile, so while rivals like Carolina went out and added Doug Weight and Mark Recchi, he picked up goaltender
Mike Morrison on waivers to back up Emery and acquired centre Tyler Arnason at the trade deadline.
The latter move was met with widespread criticism in Ottawa after Arnason recorded just four assists in 19 games and was scratched from the last couple of regular-season games and all of the playoffs.
"We made the decision that we felt our hockey club was strong enough to win," he said.
Muckler had success as a member of the
Edmonton Oilers organization in the mid-1980s through 1990 and, as he often does, made comparisons between the path the Oilers took nearly two decades ago with the one the Senators are on now.
"It's not the first time a hockey club has stumbled and never accomplished a goal," said Muckler, who has two years remaining on a three-year contract.
"As Wayne Gretzky said to a paper today, there's an organization like the Edmonton Oilers that stumbled a few times before they became champions. This is not an easy championship to win. It's the most difficult championship to win in any professional sport and we'll have to change some things and we will and our goal next year is to win the Stanley Cup."